Photo by Markus Spiske on Unsplash

I spent forty-five minutes on the phone last Tuesday trying to cancel a streaming service I'd forgotten I was paying for. Forty-five minutes. The representative kept transferring me, suggesting cheaper plans, and asking why I wanted to leave. When I finally got through to the cancellation department, I was informed I'd need to wait until the next billing cycle. That was nine days away. In 2024, this shouldn't be happening.

But it is. And it's happening to millions of people across subscription-based businesses everywhere.

The Deliberate Maze: Why Companies Make Cancellation Torture

There's no accident here. This is strategy. Companies have run the numbers and discovered something profitable: people give up on cancellations.

Research from Truecaller found that 75% of users have experienced difficulty canceling a subscription service. That's not a minority complaint—that's three out of every four people. And the companies know this. They're counting on it.

The playbook is remarkably consistent across industries. First, they make signing up embarrassingly easy. One click. Your payment information is already saved from last time. Before you know it, you're committed. Then, when you want out, suddenly the process requires navigating a labyrinth of options, waiting on hold, or worse—pretending the cancellation button doesn't exist on their website.

I've personally experienced the full spectrum of cancellation nonsense. There's the "call us to cancel" trap, where online cancellation mysteriously isn't available for your account. There's the "we lost your request" routine, where you cancel, think you're done, and then six weeks later you notice you're still being charged. Then there's my personal favorite: the deliberately confusing confirmation email that makes you wonder whether you actually canceled or just paused your subscription.

The Psychological Warfare: Designed to Make You Give Up

Companies hire people who understand behavioral psychology. They use this knowledge to create obstacles.

When you initiate a cancellation, many services will suddenly offer you discounts. "Wait! We could reduce your plan to $4.99 per month instead." It's not a genuine act of kindness. It's a test to see if you'll bite. If you decline? Now comes the guilt trip. "Are you sure? You're losing access to premium features."

Some companies have gotten even more creative. They'll ask you to rate your experience on the way out, knowing that many people will feel awkward leaving negative feedback directly to a human (or bot). Others will send you to a page with ambiguous buttons—"Pause Membership" versus "Cancel Membership"—where many users accidentally choose pause, thinking they've canceled.

The Federal Trade Commission actually sued Amazon Prime in 2023 over their cancellation practices. The company made it three clicks to sign up for Prime, but required fifteen clicks to cancel. Fifteen. Amazon claimed this was unintentional, but unintentional doesn't feed shareholders money. The company eventually agreed to make cancellation as easy as signup, but only because they were forced to.

What about the rest of them?

Who's Actually Making It Easy? (Spoiler: Almost Nobody)

I've signed up for dozens of subscriptions over the years. I can count on one hand the companies that made cancellation genuinely simple.

Netflix lets you cancel online without calling. Good for Netflix. That's table stakes now, but apparently many companies didn't get the memo. Spotify makes cancellation relatively straightforward. Apple made it easier after regulatory pressure. But these are exceptions. Most services treat cancellation like you're trying to break up with them at their parents' house.

Gym memberships remain the poster child for cancellation horror. Planet Fitness, LA Fitness, Equinox—they all have their own versions of the "you must call during business hours" or "you need to show up in person" requirements. One friend of mine finally canceled their gym membership by disputing the charge with their credit card company. The gym had made cancellation so difficult that chargebacks became more practical.

Software-as-a-Service companies are slightly better but not by much. Some still require you to email support for cancellation. Others will cancel your service but keep charging you anyway, betting you won't notice for a few billing cycles.

What You Can Do (And What Actually Needs to Change)

First, the practical stuff. Screenshot everything. When you cancel, take a screenshot of the confirmation. Save your cancellation email. Document when the charges should stop. Most importantly, check your next billing statement. Set a calendar reminder to verify the charge doesn't reappear.

You can also consider using your credit card company's built-in tools. Many cards let you authorize subscriptions through a temporary card number that auto-expires, making it easier to prevent unwanted charges. It's ridiculous that we need these workarounds, but here we are.

On a bigger level, regulation is the only thing that will fix this. The FTC's action against Amazon was important because it proved that the legal system recognizes these practices as unreasonable. California's Automatic Renewal Law requires that cancellation be as easy as signup, though enforcement remains patchy. The European Union's regulations are tighter, which is why European customers often see better treatment.

What we really need is federal legislation with real teeth. Laws that mandate one-click cancellation for all subscription services. Laws that prevent companies from continuing to charge after confirmed cancellations. Laws that fine companies substantially enough that these schemes become unprofitable.

For now, people are getting tired. The momentum against predatory subscription practices is building. If you're dealing with a particularly frustrating cancellation experience, report it to the FTC. Post about it publicly. Switch to competitors who make cancellation easy. Companies respond to market pressure and regulatory threats, sometimes in that order.

Until then, unfortunately, you'll need to approach cancellation like a military operation. Document everything. Assume nothing will go smoothly. And for what it's worth, you're not crazy for being frustrated—you're joining tens of millions of people who feel the same way.

Related reading: If you're frustrated with customer service during the cancellation process, you might also be interested in The Automated Customer Service Nightmare: Why Talking to a Robot Has Become Worse Than No Help at All, which explores how poor support systems make these situations even more infuriating.